Tuesday, March 26, 2019

CRIMINALIZATION AND DEINDUSTRIALIZATION



BY STUDENT

Deindustrialization is the process in which factories, manufacturing plants, and the general industrial capacity of a region declines. This process mostly took place during the late 19thcentury, but continues to this day- since 2001, the US has lost 42,400 factories. (Mccormack 2009).In this post I am going to talk about the effects of deindustrialization in my hometown Schenectady, New York, and how after its deindustrialization, criminal activity and violence became an issue. How did Schenectady, a small city in upstate New York become deindustrialized, and how did this affect the city itself?

Schenectady was a central location in the development of the electrical industry. It was the site of the GE Research lab, the first industrial research lab in the world, and Schenectady was known as, “The city that Lights and Hauls the World” (miSci, 2012). During WWII, GE employed over 40,000 employees in Schenectady. Currently, GE employs only 4,000.



Edison GE Company, 1891.                           Edison GE Company, 1923.

Two views of State Street, 1924.

    

Carl Company Electrical Department.   Workers around a water generator wheel.









Schenectady Works, 1980.
Images from Museum of Innovation and Science, Schenectady, New York.

Between 1970 and 200, Schenectady has had a 20.7% decrease in its population. According to the Summary of socio-economic stress indicators for New York State cities, Schenectady has an above average index of social stress, with 20.78% of residents below the poverty line, 7.24% of housing units vacant, and 22.18% of adults without a high school diploma. (Anzilotti, 2016). The property value of Schenectady from 1998 to 2003 has also decreased by -11.48% (Hevesi, 2004).

Population Trends in Schenectady from 1950 to 2000.

1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
Population
91,785
81,5682
77,958
67,972
65,566
61,821
Percent change
-11.0%
-4.6%
-12.8%
-3.5%
-5.7%

50 year percent change of -32.6%.

Table adapted from Population Trends in New York State’s Cities.

Schenectady’s economy was largely dependent on GE. As Schenectady deindustrialized and became a lower income area, white workers began to emigrate the city and its demographics changed, and it also began to be linked to crime. 

Image from Times Union.

Schenectady boasts one of the highest crime rates in New York, and its rates continue to increase. According to the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services there was a 7.6% increase in general crime in the city of Schenectady, and a 10.8% increase in violent crime, just between the years of 2000-2004. (Stratton, 2016).
Table from City of Schenectady Comprehensive Plan 2020

Schenectady’s history and current problems demonstrate how deindustrialization that leads to low income areas become linked to crime, and as Muhammad says, criminality was “crucial to the making of modern urban America.” (pg 272). A city with long history of being pivotal in technological discovery, its current city officials are now left trying to reinvent the city of invention.

Works cited
Anzilotti, Eillie, and CityLab. “Why 300 Vacant Buildings Will Light Up in Upstate New York.” CityLab, The Atlantic Monthly Group, 6 Oct. 2016, www.citylab.com/solutions/2016/09/breathing-lights-illuminates-blight-vacancy-upstate-new-york/502283/.

Hevesi, Alan G. “Population Trends In New York State’s Cities.” Www.osc.state.ny.us/Localgov/, Office of the New York State Comptroller Division of Local Government Series, Dec. 2004, www.osc.state.ny.us/localgov/pubs/research/pop_trends.pdf. 

Mccormack, Richard. “The Plight of American Manufacturing.” The American Prospect, TAP, 21 Dec. 2009, prospect.org/article/plight-american-manufacturing. 

miSci. “GE Photograph Collection.” Schenectady Museum Archives and Research, MiSci, 2012. www.misci.org/archives/ge_photograph_collection.html#subjects.

Stratton, Bryan U. “City of Schenectady Comprehensive Plan 2020.” Http://Www.cityofschenectady.com, City of Schenectady, 8 June 2016, www.cityofschenectady.com/DocumentCenter/View/215/Community-Profile-PDF. 

MUHAMMAD, KHALIL GIBRAN. CONDEMNATION OF BLACKNESS: Race, Crime, and the Making of Modern Urban America, with a New Preface. HARVARD UNIV Press, 2019.




5 comments:

  1. This post was very interesting and I like that you did research on your hometown. It goes to show that the topics learned in this class can be applied to our lives. Use of pictures, a table, and a graph was great because it gave a nice visual and it made it easier to understand the information presented. In your post you mentioned that Schenectady had an above average index of social stress, so I was wondering what the average is for New York. It would be a great comparison to add, to see just how much higher the index is in Schenectady. You linked the two topics, deindustrialization and criminalization, well. However, I would elaborate more on why low income places tend to lead to more crime. Overall, very clear and concise post with meaningful content!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was totally unaware that this was a problem in Schenectady. It's crazy to think of how dependent a city can be on a single company, and the impact its financial performance can have on people who just happen to live in the area. Definitely another problematic side effect of capitalism that doesn't get enough attention. Sure, industry can fuel the boom of a city, but it's super sketchy to depend heavily on companies that could literally go bankrupt overnight.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I live in Albany and Schenectady is very close, I didn't know this was going on in that town. This gets me thinking that this can lead to the domino effect. Since Schenectady is going through such a hard time, its only soon for near by cities if they aren't already going through de-dustrialization. I like how you did extensive research and included statics and pictures to enforce what you was explaining.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your post is very interesting and I like the way you were able to make a personal connection to the content and where you like. Although this more personal, what made your family move to Schenectady initially? How long has your family been in the area and what changes have you seen in the population and people’s reasons for settling in Schenectady?

    -Jclarke

    ReplyDelete
  5. It was interesting to learn Schenectady once had the first research lab in the world and how many employers it attracted. Then, you explained that most of the white workers emigrated to the city which reminds me of white flight in NYC. Some questions I still have are what caused the city to have such high social stress rates and are there more reported violent or property crimes? Also, how do their crime rates compare to neighboring cities such as Albany?

    ReplyDelete